fbpx
To ensure delivery by Christmas, orders must be placed before 11 am EST on Wednesday, December 18th.

Search


9″ Sugar Cream Pie – Case

An original farmhouse recipe, this pie contains only the finest ingredients including cream, sugar, and nutmeg. Our founder, Wick, built his business on Sugar Cream pie over 70 years ago, and we continue to be the largest manufacturer of this flavor. And YES, it's also the unofficial Indiana state pie!…

9″ Peanut Butter Pie – Case

A taste of childhood! Our Peanut Butter Pie has a smooth, creamy texture and a sweet, yet intense, nut flavor. We like to think of it as a cross between peanut butter fudge and peanut butter cookies. Warm or cold, this pie is a year-round pleaser.

9″ German Chocolate Pie – Case

Calling all chocolate lovers! Our German Chocolate Pie is loaded with a rich, chocolaty filling and topped with chopped Texas pecans and shredded coconut. Decadent and delicious, this pie is certain to bring smiles all around.

9″ Pumpkin Chess Pie – Case

Extra rich! Our Pumpkin Chess Pie is made with more eggs, milk and wonderful holiday spices than our traditional Pumpkin Pie; this gives it a slightly sweeter, richer flavor. Finished with a touch of cornmeal, this pie has a crispy top when warmed. We like to call it the “Pumpkin…

9″ Pumpkin Chess

Extra rich! Our Pumpkin Chess Pie is made with more eggs, milk and wonderful holiday spices than our traditional Pumpkin Pie; this gives it a slightly sweeter, richer flavor.  Finished with a touch of cornmeal, this pie has a crispy top when warmed.  We like to call it the “Pumpkin…