A holiday staple! Our classic Pumpkin Pie is baked with traditional holiday spices and lots of creamy pumpkin filling.  Smooth in texture and flavor, this original recipe from the 1950’s has stood the "taste" of time. Product Info:  1 Case (6 Pies) - 9" Baked Pumpkin Pie with 32 oz…

Peanut Butter

A taste of childhood!  Our Peanut Butter Pie has a smooth, creamy texture and a sweet, yet intense, nut flavor. We like to think of it as a cross between peanut butter fudge and peanut butter cookies.  Warm or cold, this pie is a year-round pleaser.

Sugar Cream

An original farmhouse recipe, this pie contains only the finest ingredients including cream, sugar, and nutmeg.  Our founder, Wick, built his business on Sugar Cream pie over 70 years ago, and we continue to be the largest manufacturer of this flavor.  And YES, it's also the Indiana state pie!  We…

Southern Pecan

A taste of the South!  Our Southern Pecan Pie is layered with plenty of luscious Texas pecans and a sweet, syrupy filling.  Once warmed, this nutty treat has a beautifully crisp top, a rich center, and a satisfying crunch in every bite.

Coconut Cream

We’re coco-nuts about it!  Our Coconut Cream Pie will have you sailing off into the sunset at first bite.  Our creamy, sweet filling is topped with plenty of shredded coconut that gets a toasted finish once baked.  Serve it ice-cold on a summer day or warmed up in the middle…